Research-to-practice resource
Understanding workplace expectations beyond generational labels
A research-informed resource for leaders, managers, HR, and organisational development practitioners.
Explore the findings, use the tools, and start better workplace conversations about what people need to do their best work.
The idea in one minute
Across generations, people often want similar things from work.
This research draws on the experiences of multigenerational white-collar employees in Aotearoa New Zealand. While people’s circumstances, life stages, roles, and priorities differ, the expectations they bring to work overlap far more than they diverge.
The more useful question is not which generation wants what. It is where these expectations are not being met.
Research at a glance
What you’ll find here
Research, reflection, and practical support for better workplace conversations.
Explore the part that is most useful to you today. Each section can be used on its own.
Created by
Kimberly Jane Allapitan
Master of Change and Organisational Resilience. Mind the Gap is a research-informed resource for leaders, HR, and organisational development practitioners.
Research findings
What the research found
From a survey of white-collar employees across four generations, and interviews with HR, People & Culture and OD leaders in Aotearoa New Zealand.
- 98survey respondents
- 4generations compared
- 6work dimensions measured
Summary
Key findings at a glance
1 · Expectations
2 · Gaps
3 · Commitment
4 · Suggestions
Sub-question 1
What do different generational cohorts expect?
Generations overlap far more than they differ.
Boomers, Gen X, Millennials, and Gen Z want broadly the same things from work. Across the six areas measured, only rewards showed a statistically significant difference between cohorts, and this difference was between Millennials and Gen Z. The other five areas showed no significant difference between cohorts (p = .187 to .859).
The six work dimensions measured
Org. Culture & Relationships
Feeling valued, respected, and part of an inclusive, collaborative culture.
Career Development
Progression, growth, and learning opportunities.
Rewards
Job security, fair pay, and competitive benefits.
Work-Life Balance
Flexible arrangements and boundaries between work and personal life.
Job Characteristics
Work that is interesting, innovative, and purposeful.
Technology & Digital Support
Reliable tools and support through technological change.
Expectations by generation
Grouped means per generational cohort
Boomer results (n = 6) are exploratory and should be read with caution.
1Same needs
On the whole, I mean, people are people… we want work-life balance, we want to be rewarded well, we want to feel valued.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participant
2Different stages
Everyone wants the same thing, but they just may value things differently, and different stage of your life means different things… I talk about stages.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participant
Sub-question 2
Where expectations aren't being met
The bars below show how big the gap is between what employees expect and what they feel they're actually getting. The bigger the bar, the bigger the gap.
…a priority for us is to make sure that people are given the opportunity to do their best work. And we found that… that's not always the case.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participantGaps by generation
Expectation minus fulfilment for each cohort. Warmer cells = larger unmet expectations; cooler cells = met or exceeded.
| Gen Z | Millennials | Gen X | Boomers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organisational culture & relationships | +0.22 | +0.37 | +0.92 | +0.28 |
| Career development | +0.24 | +0.16 | +0.52 | −0.50 |
| Rewards | +0.09 | +0.45 | +0.60 | +0.25 |
| Work-life balance | −0.38 | −0.32 | −0.33 | −1.17 |
| Job characteristics | −0.17 | +0.15 | −0.09 | 0.00 |
| Technology & digital support | +0.57 | +0.54 | +0.45 | +0.74 |
Gen X showed the widest gaps, most strikingly in culture and relationships (+0.92), rewards (+0.60) and career development (+0.52), with the lowest fulfilment for culture (3.09) and career development (2.95). Technology showed a gap for every cohort, and work-life balance was met or exceeded for every cohort.
Descriptive patterns given modest, unequal cohort sizes; Boomer values (n = 6) are exploratory.
Gen X has had lots of changes… and has also been through the ups and downs of the good times and the bad times. They're probably more unsettled because they know what it used to be like, and it's not like that anymore.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participantSub-question 3
What's linked to commitment and turnover
These results are correlations rather than proof of cause and effect. They show which experiences tend to move together, but they cannot tell us what causes what.
Where expectations were met, commitment tended to be higher and intention to leave lower.
Hover over or tap a link to highlight it.
Commitment and thinking of leaving
People who felt more attached to their organisation were much less likely to be thinking of leaving. The closest link of the three.
Expectations met and commitment
Where employers delivered on what people expected, people felt more emotionally attached, as psychological contract theory predicts.
Expectations met and thinking of leaving
People whose expectations were met were less likely to be thinking of leaving; where expectations fell short, intention to leave was higher.
Spearman ρ · N = 98 · all p < .001 · medium-to-large associations (Conway et al., 2011)
Which areas matter most
Longer, coloured bars mean a stronger link; grey means no meaningful link was found.
Commitment and turnover intention by generation
Mean scores on a 1 to 5 scale. Overall, commitment (3.02) and turnover intention (3.03) were both moderate on average.
Gen X and Millennials shared the lowest commitment (2.88), and Gen X reported the highest turnover intention. These are descriptive patterns; the cross-sectional data can't show whether the gaps caused them. * Boomers n = 6, exploratory.
I think more than anything else, people stay and leave because of their manager.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participantSub-question 4
What could employers do to better support employees and meet their expectations?
What employees asked for
81 of 98 respondents gave suggestions that could be coded. Percentages are based on these 81. Responses could be coded to more than one theme, so figures don't sum to 100%.
Career growth and higher pay tied as the top requests. Where pay itself couldn't move, one practitioner described transparency about how pay is set and roles are graded as the main lever left.
What practitioners said
From interviews with HR / People & Culture / OD leaders, asked what could better meet employees' expectations.
Leadership & manager capability
The most consistently emphasised theme across the interviews. Managers were described as a key channel through which employees experience culture, recognition, and development day to day.
Listening & employee voice
Practitioners described using more than annual surveys. This included pulse checks, informal conversations, and designing change with employees rather than announcing it afterwards.
Transparency & change communication
This was especially important for pay and difficult decisions. Practitioners spoke about explaining the reasoning behind a decision, and not only the decision itself, particularly when the answer cannot be "yes".
Career growth & development
Constrained in practice by flat structures, stable senior roles and limited vacancies. Clearer pathways, lateral moves, mentoring and regular conversations help, though lateral moves may not fully meet the wish to advance.
People-centred technology & future readiness
An emerging but contested area. Practitioners mentioned gradual AI onboarding, accessible learning and future-skills planning. They also spoke about helping people understand what digital change means for their work, development and job security.
No matter what interventions you're doing, design them with people. Don't start with textbooks or theory or best practice.
HR, People and OD leader · Interview participantWorkplace priorities check
Identify workplace areas worth exploring first.
Rate the everyday practices employees experience in your organisation. You will receive a starting-point list of areas to explore, and prompts for reflection and conversation. If useful, you can also complete a short follow-up on the conditions that may be helping or holding back progress.
24 short ratings across 6 workplace areas, from "Rarely or never" to "Consistently". If a statement does not apply, or you do not have enough information, you can mark it and it will be left out of your results. Your answers reflect your perspective, so check the results with employees before deciding what needs to change.
Rate your workplace
Consider six areas that shape work, including growth, pay, leadership, job design and technology.
Skip what you cannot rate
Mark a statement "Not applicable" or "Not enough information" only when it genuinely does not apply or you lack the evidence.
Pause, listen, then decide
See what to explore first and take one thoughtful conversation into your next one-to-one, team discussion or employee-listening conversation.
Privacy: This check processes answers in your browser only. It does not send ratings, notes, or downloads to a server.
Set your focus
Which part of the organisation are you looking at?
Answer for one clear area only. This makes the result more useful and helps you choose actions you can actually influence.
Set your evidence base
What will your ratings mainly be based on?
Please be honest here, as this shapes how confidently you can act on the result.
Think about typical practice over the past three months in the area you selected. Rate how consistently each statement is true, based on the information available to you and not only on policies or intentions.
Your results
Where to focus
Ordered from your lowest to highest rating. Select an area to see what the research found.
Optional next step 4 min
What’s helping or holding back progress?
Rate 12 statements about the leadership, communication and practical conditions around one workplace area. You’ll see which may be helping or holding progress back, plus one extra reflection question based on your answers.
We suggest your lowest-rated area. You can choose another.
You’ll look at
What may be helping or holding you back From your follow-up
Conditions that may affect progress on your first priority. Not part of the priority score.
Reflect before you act
Ask yourself
Then ask employees
Afterwards, tell people what you can change, what needs wider support, and when they'll hear back.
Keep in mind
This is a reflection aid, not a diagnosis. The order follows your own ratings, starting with the lowest. Where two areas have the same rating, the one more strongly linked to commitment or intention to leave in the Mind the Gap survey of 98 white-collar employees in Aotearoa New Zealand is listed first. The research context explains why each area matters, but it does not change your scores.
Optional follow-up questions
Supporting conditions to explore
Supporting conditions to explore as you work on your first priority. Not part of the priority score.
Use this check alongside employee feedback, team conversations, and relevant workforce information. The most useful next step is to validate the result with the people who experience the work every day.
Leadership reflection
Reflecting on my everyday leadership
A private reflection on what you actually do as a leader, not only what you intend. You will reflect on everyday practices, choose one to explore, and then check your view with the people you lead.
Before you start: This is a reflection aid, not a diagnostic, performance assessment or validated leadership measure. It reflects your own view, which may differ from how your team experiences your leadership. Your answers stay in your browser and are not sent or saved.
How the themes connect to the research
The eight themes are practical groupings informed by the Mind the Gap study, mainly the strategies that employees suggested and that HR and OD practitioners described (Sub-question 4 in Chapter 4). The study supports the content, but it did not test these groupings as a leadership framework.
- Leadership capability was the strategy practitioners emphasised most, and the direct manager was described as a key channel through which employees experience culture, communication, role clarity, development, recognition and support.
- Employees most often asked for growth and development (22.2%), pay (22.2%), transparency and open communication (19.8%) and stronger leadership support (14.8%), followed by culture, flexibility, training and fair workload management.
- Practitioners also stressed employee voice and co-design, explaining difficult decisions, and supporting people through digital and AI change.
The statements are research-informed reflection prompts, not a validated leadership measure. Your answers stay in your browser and are not sent or saved.
Think about typical practice over the past three months, when there was a relevant opportunity. Rate what you actually did. If you cannot recall enough examples, choose “Not sure”.
Why this theme
Leadership reflection
Your reflection
Your answers are grouped by how often you said you do each practice. Choose one that links to a recent situation, then use the prompts to think it through.
This is a reflection aid based on your own view, not a diagnosis or performance assessment. Lower ratings are a place to start reflecting, not evidence of poor leadership. Higher ratings are worth checking with others before you treat them as strengths.
Your answers at a glance
Select a practice you rated rarely, occasionally or sometimes to reflect on it.
Optional · one practical next step
What will I try more deliberately?
Avoid names and sensitive details. Your notes stay on this page until you close or refresh it.
How to read this reflection
This reflects your own recollection. Practices rated rarely or occasionally are suggested first; “sometimes” is described neutrally, and usually or consistently prompts you to check whether employees see it the same way. These bands are design choices, not validated thresholds. “Not sure” and “not applicable” answers are never treated as low.
The study lines describe what employees and practitioners reported in the research. They explain why a theme matters; they do not say anything about your own team. Check your view with employees, and use appropriate organisational channels for serious concerns.
Recommendations
From findings to action
Practical recommendations drawn from the survey and practitioner interviews. Treat them as starting points to test with employees and adapt to your context, not universal prescriptions.
About the evidence behind these suggestions
These recommendations draw on the Mind the Gap survey of white-collar employees in Aotearoa New Zealand and interviews with HR, People and OD leaders. The study was cross-sectional, used a non-probability sample and had small, uneven cohort groups. Associations don't establish cause, and the findings shouldn't be generalised to all workplaces.
The first moves, suggested partners, progress questions and action planner translate the findings into possible practices; they were not tested as interventions in this study. Life-stage explanations and the importance of flexibility for caregivers come from the interviews, not from direct subgroup testing.